patching...
Update: Fashion Gurus Wanted to Blog on Holly Springs-Hickory Flat Patch - Click Here for Details »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

BOC Responds To Grand Jury's Call For Caution

County leaders are generally positive about the grand jury's take on the upcoming HOST referendum.

 

Cherokee County Commissioners are responding to calls for caution by the Cherokee County grand jury on the upcoming Nov. 6 referendum on a homestead option sales tax.

The interim grand jury issued the presentment on Monday, which "strongly urge the residents of Cherokee County to research this new proposal before the upcoming November election."

"We also urge county residents to read and understand the language of the two questions that will appear on the November ballot," it stated.

While the proposal is revenue neutral for the county, the grand jury also urged residents to "be aware the new provision is a permanent tax unless repealed and does not put in place any restrictions on changing in the millage rate or assessment value for property."

The grand jury made the presentment after speaking with Cherokee County Chief Financial Officer Janelle Funk about the proposal. 

District Attorney Garry Moss said he can't speak to why the grand jury made the recommendation.

He noted Funk spoke with the grand jury for about an hour. Moss also indicated this wasn't the first time the jury has weighed in on items on the ballot. The district attorney said similar presentments "has occurred on past SPLOST (Special Purpose Local Option Sales Tax) questions." 

How do you feel about the proposed Homestead Option Sales Tax? Tell us in the comments and in our poll below!

County Commission Chairman Buzz Ahrens had a "simple" response to the grand jury's assessment.

"Any message that gets voters to inform themselves is positive, regardless of how the message was delivered," he said. 

Ahrens has been at the forefront of the county's efforts to educate voters about the HOST, participating in two forums sponsored by Cherokee Bank and the Cherokee Tribune designed to inform voters about the proposal. He's also made the rounds at city council meetings to discuss the issue. He was at the Ball Ground City Council last night to discuss the proposal.

County Commissioner Harry Johnston noted he "certainly" agreed with the grand jury's recommendation.

He reiterated that the benefit of the HOST will not be for the county government, but will be for county homeowners. Johnston noted that when he's discuss the HOST with homeowners, he's discovered that almost all are in favor of the proposal. He noted the only exception he's encountered is a homeowner who owns a "modest home, but spends an unusually large amount on taxable purchases."

"And remember that Cherokee is in the good position that we will be able to offset 100 percent of the county M&O (maintenance and operation) tax for homestead properties and have enough HOST proceeds left to offset 50 percent to 70 percent for all other properties," he said. "So it's not just homeowners that benefit. It's all property owners. Homeowners just benefit more."

County Commissioner Jim Hubbard said the misinformation being circulated by the HOST is based upon the "distrust" many residents have of politicians. He noted Cherokee County has "some honest and dedicated elected officials," and the HOST would allow the county to join in the statewide trend of counties "who use sales tax to provide tax relief for the residents."

Along with Cherokee, Cobb and Gwinnett counties are the only counties that do not use sales taxes to provide tax relief to property owners. 

Hubbard said he agreed with the grand jury's statement, but "not for the same reasons."

"People should study this for themselves," he said. "There are some people using this opportunity to further their political agenda, with no regard for what is best for the residents. I believe that if people look at the true facts, this will pass by a good margin, and the people will see the tax relief on their October 2013 tax bills."

See the attached document provided by Commissioner Johnston on the proposed HOST referendum. 

Don’t miss any Woodstock news. Subscribe to Woodstock-Towne Lake Patch’s free newsletterlike us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

  • Do you support the proposed one-percent Homestead Option Sales Tax, which would be used to rollback county property taxes?

    (Voting has been closed for this question)
    • Yes.
        1 (14%)
    • No.
        5 (71%)
    • I have no idea what you're talking about.
        1 (14%)
    Total votes: 7
  • Your vote will only count once. This is not a scientific poll. View Results Vote!
Related Topics: Cherokee County Commission, Homestead Option Sales Tax, and cherokee county grand jury

Roy Bryant

10:22 am on Friday, October 12, 2012

I don't see how a property owner in Cherokee County could not vote for the HOST tax. Cobb, Gwinett along with Cherokee are the only counties in the Metro who do not have HOST for property owners.

Reply
Comment_arrow
Patch_comments_icon

Kristal Dixon

10:24 am on Friday, October 12, 2012

Thanks for submitting the comment!

Frank Jones

11:14 am on Friday, October 12, 2012

The Grand Jury's advice is extremely wise and is based upon caution and skepticism based upon the past failures of the County Commissioners. Besides their mishandling of the Bobo affair, a reasonable person who does the math will see that the numbers "just don't work"! A reasonable person will see their are specific Winners and specific Losers. Most of the county's residents will be Losers.

The commissioners claim HOST is good for homeowners since their property taxes will be lower. However, there is no free money and property taxes will only be lower because they'll be paying more sales taxes. Not only will they be paying sales taxes to reduce their property taxes, they'll be paying to reduce the M&O portion of commercial, rental and vacant land by up to 70%. Homeowners will be giving corporations and high net worth individuals a tax break!

A family that "breaks-even" due to HOST (i.e. M&O reduction = add'l Sales Tax paid) could actually pay up to 41% more since property taxes are deductible on their taxes while sales tax isn't!

Renters and those living in what Hubbard refers to as "modest" homes will be the biggest losers! They'll receive the no benefit or little benefit and yet pay substantially more in sales taxes.

Once passed, the BOC can raise millage rates to negate the M&O reduction AND keep the extra 1% sales tax. That's what other counties have done and staff in the county office say will happen!

I'm not Tea-Party or have political ambition.

Reply

Georgia Moderate

7:54 pm on Saturday, October 20, 2012

@Frank, while I oppose the HOST - for different reasons - I believe it is highly suspicious that the grand jury chose to use their power to enter into what is a political discussion. Impartiality of the grand jury is key to maintaining the public's trust in the institution. And it is obvious that this presentment demonstrates clear bias by the grand jury against the ballot question by its admonitory language, and by association, against its supporters.

There is legal precedent in Georgia (Kelley v. Tanksley, 1961) that presentments which "...by innuendo and implication cast reflections of misconduct..." can be expunged from the record.

One would hope that those elected officials who have most publicly supported the HOST, would have the courage and fortitude to declaim this presentment and file to have it expunged.

Reply

Leave a comment